Monday, October 5, 2020

No Innocence Here: How Irish, Jewish and Italian New Yorkers Benefited From Their Whiteness in Post World War 2 NYC

Whenever I engage in conversations about race with Irish, Jewish or Italian New Yorkers of my generation- or those slightly younger- I am likely to confront some variety of the following argument " I am sick of all this talk about white privilege. Not only did my immigrant ancestors have nothing to do with slavery and segregation, but they faced terrible discrimination when they came here. Moreover, they climbed out of poverty- and finally won acceptance- through generations of hard work, not by asking for handouts or special help from the government. Frankly, I am tired of Black people holding us hostage as though they are the only ones who suffered. If they have problems, it is their own fault." I would be lying if I told you that I have developed a successful response to such comments. People who express such sentiments are deeply invested in the aura of injured innocence they convey. Talking about how the wealth accumulated by slavery made the immigration of their ancestors possible is too abstract to make headway with peope who pride themselves on their practicality and common sense. Plus this all happened almost two hundred years ago. However, the more research I do on Bronx history, and the more discussions i have with my students about this subject, the more i realize that Irish, Italian and Jewish New Yorkers reaped huge advantages over their Black counterparts in post-World War 2 New York, advantages which accelerated their movement into the middle class in a period of unprecedented economic expansion. Black New Yorkers also progressed during these critical years-1945-1960- but their rate of progress was sharply limited by discrimination they faced in housing and employment markets, discrimination that, ironically, was often imposed by people whose ethnic background once made them the targets of discrimination themselves No where was this more visible than in the explosion of middle income housing in NYC and environs after the Second World War. In addition to entirely new suburban communities such as Levittown Long Island, you had middle income apartment complexes such as Parkchester in the Bronx, Stuyvesant Town in Manhattan, the Trump Houses in Coney Island, and the Levitt apartments in Queens. If you add to these the four miles of beautiful apartment buildings along the Grand Concourse in the Bronx, you have the portrait of a great American success story of upward mobility and middle class ascendency. You can also see this a triumph of assimilation as the overwhelming majority of occupants of this housing were Irish Jewish and italian. However, such a celebratory portrait can only be sustained by ignoring one stubborn fact--Every single one of these housing complexes, which in total contained hundreds of thousands of residents, maintained "white only" policies and kept Black tenants and home buyers out. If you were Black even if you had a good income, even if you were eligible for loans from the GI Bill, you couldn't rent an apartment along the Grand Concourse, in Parkchester or Stuyvestant town, in the Trump or Levitt Houses, and you couldn't buy a home in Levittown. Worse yet, these policies, challenged by civil rights groups through lawsuits and complaints to Human Rights Commissions, didn't change until the 1960's And just in case someone asked, the people who enforced these policies, as well as those who lived in the communities in question, were not Southern segregationists, but Irish, Jewish and italian New Yorkers who once faced discrimination themselves! You see a similar pattern in post world war 2 labor markets. Three of the most vibrant industries in post war NYC were construction, banking and insurance. Black people were completely excluded from all three of these industries until the late 1960's, And while you could argue that banking and insurance were for the most park white Protestant enclaves, in which Irish and Jewish people had created hard won enclaves, construction in NYC, in the post war era, almost exclusively employed Irish and Italian workers, especially in the most highly skilled categories And here you have an terrible irony- construction in NYC after WW 2, entirely populated by the descendents of once despised European immigrants, enforced a lily white policy that limited access of Black people to the highest paying blue collar jobs in NYC Think about what you have just read: when you limit access to the best housing and the best jobs in a city on the basis of race, you are severely handicapping the economic progress of those facing these bans. These were barriers Black people faced alone in post war NYC. Their Irish, Jewish and Italian counterparts didn't suffer the same fate when color lines were drawn. And sadly, tragically, they were often the ones drawing the lines


Colinsh said...

awesome blog! i am share this with my friends

Unknown said...

To earn a living most longshoremen had to pay kickbacks, volunteer to work at a moment’s notice, or consistently make themselves available for overtime. But, as I. Philip Sipser, a lawyer who represented black Local 968, put it, they “got the worse piece of shit . . . every lousy job that had to be filled because white workers wouldn’t do it.” Banana shipments, for example, were generally considered black cargo because, as Sipser explained, in the banana boats there were “rats as big as cats down there . . . stink was terrible . . . dirty work.”
Be- lieving his discussion was off-the-record, Pier Superintendent Clyde Walters ac- knowledged “the only jobs available to Negroes . . . are mule jobs in the hold of the ship.” That “Negroes are never selected as dockmen, drivers or checkers.” The “hiring agents select ‘neighborhood children’ in filling all categories of work except for the back-breaking hold jobs.” That is the “immediate residential com- munity of white, primarily Irish and Italian” longshoremen. Walters added that to “buck the ‘system’” was to invite “all types of reprisals” by the men. These “reprisals” included “slow-downs, quickie strikes, damaging of equipment, phy- sical violence, etc.”

Rohit said...

You actually understand how to bring an issue How To Transfer Mobile Internet Data

๐–‡๐–Š๐–™๐–˜๐–†๐–—๐–†๐–“๐–Œ885♡ said...

You have a good point here!I totally agree with what you have said!! Thanks for sharing your views. hope more people will read this article!! ๊ฒฝ๋งˆ

Sarah Winget said...

It takes a couple of snaps to score high grades through our finance assignment help administration. Our top-quality student/school assignment help specialists convey arrangements inside the briefest pivot time. assignment provider

Ina said...

the specialists in psychology comprehend the psychological elements of an individual and afterward help them with the best arrangement which can help them in the most ideal manner. With the comprehension of the psychological capacities, investigate the universe of the neurological butt-centric physiological interaction too. visit - my assignment help

bet-mantotopro said...

Hello my friend! I want to say that this post is amazing, nice written and come
with approximately all important infos. I’d like to look more posts like this .
์˜จ๋ผ์ธ์นด์ง€๋…ธ said...

์นด์ง€๋…ธ์‚ฌ์ดํŠธ Thank you so much for ding the impressive job here, everyone will surely like your post.

Unknown said...

nice information...Good blog. If you want want know, more click here.
dnd 5e dissonant whispers
dissonant whispers 5e
kim k wedding hair

sportstotolink said...

Thanks a lot for sharing this with all people you actually realize what you’re talking approximately! ํ† ํ† ์‚ฌ์ดํŠธ

roulettesitetop said...

This is a great source of information, I will keep track of your posts and share them with everyone ๋ฃฐ๋ ›

sportstototopcom said...

You have a very good site, well constructed and very interesting i have bookmarked you hopefully you keep posting new stuff ์Šคํฌ์ธ ํ† ํ† 

Adnan said...

nice information...Good blog. If you want want know, more click here.
YouTube video download
YouTube video download y2mate
Google Translate Malay to English

casinositetop ์นด์ง€๋…ธ์‚ฌ์ดํŠธ said...

Such an interesrting and essential topic that everyone should know this. keep posting Feel free to visit my website; ์นด์ง€๋…ธ์‚ฌ์ดํŠธ๋งํฌ

oncasinosite ์นด์ง€๋…ธ์‚ฌ์ดํŠธ said...

I just got to this amazing site not long ago. I was actually captured with the piece of resources you have got here. Big thumbs up for making such wonderful blog page Feel free to visit my website; ๋ฐฐํŠธ๋งจํ† ํ† ํ”„๋กœ

Azeemali said...

nice information...Good blog. If you want want know, more click here.
Cloud of Daggers 5e
How to Refresh Outlook
Montreal Canadian tickets

Rosemarie Cozart said...

I found your information to be very interesting. Thanks for sharing. A useful profile on the subject cps tester. This is useful for increasing clicking speed. Many people liked it.

Anonymous said...

We have talked with one of the Oily skin person Rosy. "My skin was so oily since childhood and it was really irritating for me. I can't be confident even while i go to party or else to a function, everyone stares at my oil skin and i have to feel the shy. This is where I came across the  from the Yuglo skin where the  is one of the best products which makes my face very smooth, free from oil and looks so great. Since then I have become an evid fan of the natural skin care brand. Especially the Natural Ingredients makes the brand so unique because these days we are seeing so many chemicals used products. Even though, their results might be faster but in the long run, we are going to have issues while using such kind of brands. Hence I recommend Yuglo for any women who is looking for organic and natural products for their hair, face and skin".

While when we got the opportunity to speak with one of the dry skin women Ily. Ily said "My skin was dry all the time and it is really frustrating experience for me, especially, I stay in the cold regions and when there is heavy cold, you can clear see the layers coming out from the lips and skin due to dryness, that is where i tried the  from the Yuglo. I apply it at thee night time before i sleep and while i woke up in the morning, i am going to have a great and nice experience, My skin feels better and i also tried the  from this organic brand. I applied it for a month and you don't and you don't believe me the results are fantastic. I am using both their Peach Lips mask and Face mask for the skin since past 2 years and i would love to try their new products as well in the future. Thanks to the yuglo skin for bringing such awesome products and great thing is they are available at an affordable pricing. It merely costs me $25 per month to try their products and have a healthy skin routine.

Types of Products to improve Skin Care

When it comes to the types of the products, there are so many people who are trying the natural face masks by seeing the youtube videos and improving their skin care. There are majorly three types of skins, one is oily, the other is dry and the third one is mixed. Especially those with Oily skin always suffer due to their face looks quiet odd due to the excess oil on their face and they feel so bad about it. 
This is where the Organic products of skin care has come in handy for these kind of people. While people who are having a mixed dry and oily skin, not had to suffer much but still they can improve their skin tone using the Lip mask product from amazon. This product is bought by more than 100000+ happy customers and has an average rating of 4.5 with more than 5500 reviews. 

They have products which are related to hair, face and lips. Especially their lip sleeping mask is the best seller and next comes, the face mask which is also quiet good seller for them. They also have face oil and new vanilla flavor for the lips, they want to become one of the top skin care brands in the future by solving all the issues related to the skin care. They also have the face moisturizer which is one of the best among the face moisturizers compared to others as those comes with the natural ingredients which everyone will love than compared to unnatural and chemical ingredients.

Bilal said...

nice information...Good blog. If you want want know, more click here.
jaa lifestyle login
lay on hands dnd 5e

Gaurav said...

taurus woman traits She keeps her emotions to herself most of the time. · She loves the simple pleasures in life and that includes food.

Arthur Wilson said...

Global Assignment Help is an assignment help platform, which helps the students of the United States of America, Canada, United Kingdom, Australia, and New Zealand, by providing them plagiarism-free quality assignments on time. There are more than 500 Ph.D. experts, associated with the organization, who are renowned for enhancing the quality of the assignments with proper and correct information about the concepts and recent development in the respective fields. The afterwork services like editing, and proofreading are done with regards to the academic standards, and required customization. Many students have scored well, and became successful in their academic careers with the assistance of the firm. Moreover, the round the clock customer services, and the affordable price range makes them one of the best assignment help service providers in the world.

My Assignment Help said...

Thank you for sharing this informative blog post.
Marketing assignments can seem overwhelming without the right help. My Assignment Help is here to make that homework a breeze. Our expert writers will craft a marketing plan tailored to your specific assignment instructions, highlighting key marketing strategies and concepts in an easy-to-understand manner. Leave the all-nighters behind and hand in an assignment you can be proud of. Whether you need help with developing marketing objectives, identifying target markets, creating marketing mixes, or evaluating marketing campaigns, our writers have the expertise to craft an organized, thorough marketing assignment that achieves high marks. Let our experienced writers take the stress out of your Marketing Assignment Help so you can focus on enjoying the rest of your semester.