Tuesday, July 29, 2014

Arne Duncan Drops in Unexpectedly on Meeting With BATS at US Department of Education Office of Civil Rights and Gets an Earful!



   On July 28, 2014, following the  BAT Rally outside the US Department of Education, a delegation of BATS went up to  the Education Department’s Office of Civil Rights to share some of the main issues that BATS had with  Department Policy.  Representing the BATS were Marla Kilfoyle, General Manager of BATS. Dr Yohuru Williams of Fairfield University, Chicago BAM (Badass Moms) leader  Shoneice Reynolds and her son Asean Johnson, Tennessee BAT leader Larry Proffitt, and Dr Mark Naison, co founder of BATS. The meeting had been set up by Marla Kilfoyle through an official of the Department of Education’s Office of Communications.

  Arne Duncan was not originally scheduled to attend the meeting, but dropped in unexpectedly in the middle. What follows  is my  account of the meeting, including the dialogue with Mr. Duncan, along with and some reflections on what it all means.  How much of what transpired will lead to further communication and action, and how much represented a “smoke and mirrors” game by officials of the Department remains to be seen.

   After going through security, we were escorted to a conference room in the
US Ed Department’s Office of Civil Rights, where we were met by 9 people, including a senior staff member of the Office of Civil Rights, Robert Kim, who chaired the meeting, along with staff members from the Offices of Communications and Community Outreach and several student interns with the Department.  Mr Kim, who chaired the meeting, was very cordial and asked us if we could present our major concerns, saying he hoped we could find areas of agreement as well as areas where we disagreed, and that a dialogue could  develop which would hopefully continue after the meetings.

    When Mr. Kim asked if someone would present the groups major concerns, I stepped forward, I decided to do so in a manner which would focus attention  on Department of Education policies that  maximized educational  inequality and violated the civil rights of students, parents and teachers in inner city and working class communities.   Using my own experiences in the Bronx as a reference point, I said that BATS were deeply concerned with how Race to the Top Policies, which required rating schools and teachers on the basis of student test scores, closing allegedly “failing schools,” and  preferring charter schools over public schools had the following consequences:

    Leading  teachers in vulnerable neighborhoods to “teach to the test” to the detriment of activities which fostered student creativity.
   Leading to the use of recess time, gym time, and after school time to test prep, maximizing health problems in poor and working class neighborhoods
    Leading the mass firing of veteran teachers and a sharp decline in the percentage of teachers of color on many cities.
     Leading to the destabilization of neighborhoods and the smothering of parent, teacher and student voices in the shaping of education policy.
     Leading to the demonization of public school teachers and their being blamed for everything from the achievement gap for the persistence of poverty and inequality.
     Leading to the best young teachers leaving  the profession prematurely
     

     The irony here, I said, was that these policies, promoted with  Civil Rights rhetoric, were riding roughshod over the Civil Rights of residents of inner city communities.  I asked for a two year moratorium on all these policies- no more school closings, no more VAM, no more charter school creation- and a new effort by the US Department Education to have teachers voices have a primary role in shaping Department policy rather than business leaders.

       My remarks appeared to catch many of the officials there by surprise. Several agreed with what I was saying; others tried to defend Department of Education policies and say states were ultimately responsible for the abuses I was describing
       
        The points of agreement expressed by Department of Education officials who spoke up were on the following issues:

 Need to reverse the declining percentage of teachers or color
Need to stop best young teachers from leaving the profession
 Need to stop use of recess and gym for test prep
Need to end demonization of teachers by public officials

    However, several of the officials, while agreeing that we needed to address the above problems insisted that school closings, charter school preferences, and the use of test scores to rate teachers and schools were not the sources of those problems

  As this point, Shoneice Reynolds, Asean Johnson, and Larry Proffitt entered the conversation forcefully and eloquently.  Shoneice and Asean talked in depth about how  in Chicago, community schools were first  starved, then closed and charter schools put in their place, smothering and stifling parent voices, depriving children of great neighborhood schools, and making Chicago neighborhoods more dangerous.   They gave example after example of one great program after another being eliminated in public schools, while charter schools were created which were often limited in their programming and abusive in their discipline policies.
Larry Profitt described how rating teachers on the basis of test scores was driving the best teachers out of the profession in almost every school district in Tenneessee and were severely constricting the curriculum.  Both put the blame squarely on the US Department of Education for promoting policies which led to those destructive consequences and for promoting rhetoric which demonized teachers.
       Right in the middle of both of these conversations, Arne Duncan walked in and introduced himself! Needless to say, we were surprised because we were told he would NOT be at the meeting.  Especially since he entered, along with one of his top aides,  just as things were starting to get heated and real disagreements were emerging.
      Secretary Duncan after  introducing himself,  and saying that he could only stay for a few minutes, asked for two things; first if  we could articulate our concerns about the Department’s policies on dealing with Special needs students, and secondly, if Shoneice and Asean could step out with him to talk about what was going on in Chicago.
      In response to his first comment, Marla Kilfoyle started speaking about her concerns about Department from her standpoint of the parent of a special needs student as well as a teacher. She said it appeared that Department policies  were forcing school districts to disregard individual student IEP’s and exposing special needs students to inappropriate and abusive levels of testing.
       Secretary Duncan deflected her remarks by saying that the Department was concerned that too many children of color were being inappropriately diagnosed as being Special Needs children  and that once they were put in that category they were permanently marginalized. He then said “We want to make sure that all student are exposed to a rigorous curriculum.”
        At that point, I interrupted him in a very loud voice and said “ We don’t like the word ‘rigor.” We prefer to talk about creativity and maximizing students potential.”
        Secretary Duncan was someone taken aback by my comments. He said “ we might disagree about the language, but what I want is for all students to be able to take advanced placement courses or be exposed to an IB (International Baccalaureat) curriculum
       At this point, Larry Proffitt interrupted the Secretary  and said that in Tennessee, Special Needs students were being abused and humiliated by abusive and inappropriate testing and that their teachers knew this, and were afraid to speak out.
       We were clearly at an impasse here, which the Secretary dealt with by saying he had to leave and asking Shoneice and Asean to step into the hall with him and continue the conversation.
        The rest of us in the room were all now  pretty confused and more than a little upset.  However, Robert Kim spoke up and said that the rest of the DOE staff were ready to spend up to a half an hour more continuing the conversation, and hopefully we could develop some consensus on areas of agreement and ways of continuing the dialogue.
    Now, things started to get really interesting!  The woman from the Communications office who hadn’t previously spoken up, said that she was concerned about how angry teachers were at the Department since because it was her experience that every time Secretary Duncan travelled to a new city, he met with teachers to hear their concerns.   I then said, perhaps impolitely, that the Secretary fueled teacher mistrust  by making statement after statement showing disrespect for teachers, from his support of the firings of Central Falls Rhode Island teachers in 2009, to his comments on Hurricane Katrina and New Orleans public schools, to his support of Cathy Black for NYC school chancellor, to his recent endorsement of the Vergara decision undermining teacher due process.    “Maybe if you can tell him to stop making provocative comments like these,” I said, “maybe teachers will regard the Department more favorably.”
  At this point, Dr Yohuru Williams chimed in with a suggestion for how the Department could genuinely welcome teacher voices- calling a “National Teachers Congress”- where teachers from all over the country could come together to frankly express their concerns about Department of Education policies.  He added “those teachers can’t be handpicked to say what the Department wants to hear, they have to be democratically  selected.”  His suggestion was discussed for several minutes and the Communication directors promised to give it serious consideration. This was one of the few talking points in the meeting from which there might be some serious follow up
    After this the director of Community outreach and one of the interns started critiquing our perspective that federal policies were driving the best teachers out of the profession, stifling creativity in the classroom, and leading to a decline in teachers of color.  In doing so they  started defending school  closings and VAM, asking us whether  there were any circumstances under which schools should be close and whether there was any method of evaluating teachers that did not rely on student test scores.
     At this point, Dr Williams spoke up, saying that in Connecticut, the suppression of community voices in cities like Bridgeport by unelected school boards was being justified by arguments that mayoral control was supported, if not required Race to the Top, and that similar dynamics were at play in Hartford and New London.  “Does the US Department of Education support real democracy in education decision making,” Dr. Williams he asked?”
     They two officials had no real answer to what Dr Wiliams was saying and deflected attention from his critique by insisting that we needed to hold teachers accountable by student test scores because there was no other way of making sure teachers took every student seriously and helped all of them reach their full potential.
     Now things started to get really heated. Larry Proffitt said that teaching to the test is not real teaching and to have students full potential unleashed , you needed teachers to give them individual attention and kinds of in depth instruction and inspiration that no bubble test could measure.  I said VAM was a disaster, along with the rest of  Race to the Top and we need a two year moratorium on test based teacher evaluation.
      Robert Kim then entered as a peacemaker and said “how can we keep this discussion going?”. We said, call us back. We are glad to continue a discussion about how to best get teacher voices more input into Department policy, how to find forms of assessing teacher quality that do not depend on student test scores, and how to attract and retain more great teachers, especially teachers of color. 
    Mr. Kim and the two Communications office said they would find ways of keeping the conversation going, and then called an end to the meeting.
     We left the meeting feeling that we had spoken frankly, that we had been heard, that some people agreed with our main points, while others disagreed. 
      However, nothing concrete had been achieved. There were no policy changes that anyone had agreed to and certainly no overall agreement to reverse the directions of Race to the Top.
       There were a few small glimmers of hope at the end of the meeting. Mr Kim, the top Civil Rights official ,  came up to me after the meeting and said that he really liked our group, that he would try to find ways of keeping the conversation going, and that he would like to meet with me the next time he came to New York. I agreed to remain in communications with him.  Through the entire meeting, he had been respectful, helpful and astute.
     Then, after everyone else left, another staff member from the Office of Civil Rights came up to me and said he really liked what we had to say. What could their office do right now to help us?   I thought a second and said to him “ Investigate charter school abuses. All over the nation, unregulated charters are employing disciplinary practices and expelling students in ways which would not be acceptable in a public school. If your office would start investigating such practices as civil rights violations, it would make a huge difference.”
      He smiled at me and said “Thanks for the suggestion. I will look into it.”
      His response gave me a glimmer of hope that some of the ten plus people in that room were on the same page as BATS on a few issues, even though the Secretary was clearly unmoved by anything we said.
     We spoke truth to power, without fear and without compromise.
      Whether we will be called back to continue the conversation only time will tell.
    

   

     

194 comments:

Peggy said...

I hope those out there that care about the things you brought up there will consider this- they need to sue.

be careful said...

Thank you so much for this summary. But Arne took the kids? Did an adult go with them? That was the scariest part. Tweeting to humanity .

Carl Petersen said...

https://petitions.whitehouse.gov/petition/fire-arne-duncan/2gNq0vgP

AJC4Others said...

Have the m look into the URBAN HOPE ACT. by its very name shows it is targeted at a certain type of US Citizen and population. NJ legislators have carved out Camden NJ as a money pit they can fill their troughs from and protect, recommend for office, and give jobs to only those willing to drink from the trough. Meanwhile, that trough rests on the back of urban children and federal dollars which the corrupt continuously "mismanage" without audit or accountability, or criminal prosecution.

Mike Klonsky said...

With all due respect Mark, It sounds like Duncan played BATS like an old fiddle. Let 'em blow off steam. Pat 'em on the head. Divide and conquer. Agree to disagree. Did DOE crats at least serve tea and cookies?

Mark Naison said...

Mike:

It was exactly what I expected, kind of like I was on the O'Reilly factor. All you can hope for is to get your main talking points across/
We did that. I never expected anything much to come out of this. with the possible exception of some more serious investigation of Charter School abuses. And even there, I would not hold my breath

Unknown said...

Duncan may have played the politician, but the fact that he stepped in says two things: 1) he realized that BATS had made enough noise that he had to at least make an appearance and 2) that he probably recognized the tension in the room and tried to smooth it out. As others have said, getting rid of Duncan is about impossible, but getting someone to look at Civil Rights issues might be more important. Kudos to all who spoke the truth.

Unknown said...

Thank you for being there and expressing our concerns vocally, forcibly, and with respect. Even if they do nothing with what was said. It is a starting point. Before yesterday no one was even listening with any recognition to us from the DOE. Now we just need to continue to immobilize and continue the work. Not just say well we talked to them and they didn't listen.

Unknown said...

Thank you for doing this for us all. It only takes one to plant the seed and get this conversation going. I sincerely hope that this conversation will continue as both sides indicated. Any word on what happened in regards to the other conversation with Shoneice and Asean?

Unknown said...

Mark - what was discussed between Duncan and the other BATS?

Unknown said...

Thank you! Thank you! Thank you!

Anonymous said...

Many charter schools exist, at least in my state, because they are what parents want. Parents are on charter school boards and if the discipline looks harsher than traditional public school (a charter school is a public school) might it be because it is what parents want? They are tired of the few disruptive kids preventing the others from learning. Some parents want not only teachers held accountable but district administrators because teachers can't be expected to have great results in overcrowded classrooms (especially when the disruptors are allowed to remain) and teach without adequate materials. (Disembodied photocopied pages are not quality materials.) And yes, many parents want rigor to go with all that required seat-time. (Mr. Duncan is misguidedly pushing more seat-time. The better scores for affluent kids are not due to them having more seat-time than the rest. Instead they have enriching activities outside of school from birth on.)

laMissy said...

"After this the director of Community outreach and one of the interns started critiquing our perspective that federal policies were driving the best teachers out of the profession, stifling creativity in the classroom, and leading to a decline in teachers of color. In doing so they started defending school closings and VAM, asking us whether there were any circumstances under which schools should be close and whether there was any method of evaluating teachers that did not rely on student test scores."

It seems to me that all these folks have been fed is the KoolAide. Did you get the feeling that these staffers are all novices, without any ed background whatsoever? After all, eval by VAM is a new thing, and teacher evaluations have been around at least for 40 years, which is when I began teaching. And we didn't used to just close schools as a "solution".

Mark Naison said...

From Monty Neill of Fair Test:

I believe Robert Kim used to work with NEA. From limited contact with him there (if it is he), I would expect him to take BATS and allied views seriously - but he does work for Duncan, from whom there is no evidence he takes critiques of testing and privatization seriously.Still, need to talk with them, see what they say in meetings and as you did, report. And their meeting means they recognize you.

CR is not going to get at the heart of the problem (testing and privatization and attendant damage to kids, teachers, schools, public education), but they may help address important issues as they have done to a meaningful extent on school discipline (so say allies working closely on this issue). So pushing them to look more closely at charters could help some kids.

Also: Shoneice is Asean's mother, so itwas not two childen who went off with Duncan - who is significantly responsible for the Chicago disasters, along with predecessor Vallas and other since, under mayors Daley and Emmanuel.

Unknown said...

Thanks! Duncan should be in this position...He is a horrible human being and has no idea what special ed parents go through on an everyday basis.....Thanks to him our children will not graduate if this continues....Our children cant sit through a 2 hour final and be expected to pass....They need to break it up and allow them to process information and be able to answer the question. I am not taking about State tests as my children refused to take those unnecessary tests. I am taking about the end of the year finals that they must pass or they have to keep taking until they pass....These things must change....They need sample tests to study from and that is never given as it is hush hush what is on these new tests....So thanks ARNE DUNCAN you are the reason we are going to have a decline in gradation rates in our future

Unknown said...

I meant shouldn't be in this position...sorry typo

Lance said...

Is the Teacher Congress idea at the conceptual stage or beyond? If the later, is there a "job description"?
link?

Anonymous said...

I'm sending this to the ACLU. I can see a strong cause for action against voucher and charter schools. For voucher they wont be defended on the citizen's dime.

Anonymous said...

Thank you for your bold and courageous action on the part of Badass teachers, parents, and students everywhere. Even if they are only patronizing us and spewing the reform rhetoric, they have acknowledged BATs are a force to be reckoned with. I agree with Mike K, they have their ways of dealing with dissent, "Let 'em blow off steam. Pat 'em on the head. Divide and conquer. Agree to disagree." If they think this will just go away, they have miscalculated. Whether or not we can dump Duncan, this could very well blow up into a huge campaign issue in the next few years as we mobilize parents and demand accountability from elected officials for selling out our public education system. Looks like BATs are out for blood!

tisha said...

Thanks for the informative blog dear. I am also planning for that I am looking for a good and a convenient meeting room. If you have any recommendation for me, then please do share.

Unknown said...

Charlotte Meeting Rooms
Very informative

Anjali said...

uniraj msc previous final time table
uniraj mcom previous final time table
rtu 4th sem revaluation result
rtu b.tech 7th semester result
rtu b.tech 1st semester result

Unknown said...


secunderabad rrb call letter
secunderabad ntpc admit card
non technical status
kolkata rrb call letter
ahmedabad non technical admit card
non technical call letter
bhopal cbt admit card
bhopal ntpc call letter

Unknown said...


BSEO HSC Result
Mizoram Board Results
MAHA Results
UP Results
RBSE Results
CBSE Results

Unknown said...

It's really very useful post.
ssc cgl result

Unknown said...

Thank you for the useful information. Check Karnataka PUC Results So

Unknown said...

Click here for best teeth whitening treatments.
best teeth whitening treatments

Unknown said...

Get the complete details about current silver rate/price in India. For more click here
silver rate in india

Unknown said...

SBI Clerk Exam Notification released. Here you can get the complete details about SBI clerk notification.
SBI Clerk Notification

Unknown said...

IBPS RRB Clerk Online Application available here. click here for more details of IBPSRRB Clerk Online application and how to apply.
IBPS RRB Clerk Application Form

Unknown said...

Check TS EDCET Result 2017 Declared. Aspirants who appeared for the Bed Entrance Exam can check the TS Edcet 2017 result on this portal.
TS EDCET Result

kingrani said...

Flipkart is Offering Cashback Offers Flipkart deal of the day offers You will get upto 75% Discount

Flipkart is Offering Cashback Offers Flipkart Daily Deals You will get upto 75% Discount

Flipkart is Offering Cashback Offers Flipkart Deals & Offers You will get upto 75% Discount

Flipkart is one of the biggest world wide eCommerce Site flipkart cashback offersso

Flipkart is one of the biggest world wide eCommerce Site Flipkart hdfc offersso

bhuvana teja said...

Good Website


RRB ALP Syllabus

Unknown said...

List of IFB Washing Machine in India with their lowest online prices. Find the best washing machines by clicking on the below link.
ifb washing machine

Unknown said...

Compare prices for Top 10 Under 40000 Refrigerators in India and read reviews. Further you can checkout the best price available for these Refrigerators from this site.
top refrigerator under 40000

Unknown said...

Price list of all 55 Inch LED televisions in India with all features, review & specifications. For more click here
55 Inch LED TV

Karthik Jessie said...

rrb Guwahati ALP syllabus/ so

rrb Jammu ALP syllabus/ so

punneth said...

You can download any apk latest version from here
apk downloads

Unknown said...

free themes box

premium wordpress themes free download

wordpress themes free download

free responsive wordpress themes

ae templates free download

download wordpress themes free

after effects templates free download
blogger templates free download

wordpress themes nulled

adobe after effects projects free download

themeforest wordpress theme free download

adobe after effects projects free download

Karthik Jessie said...

Download Uttarakhand Ayush Pre-Medical Test Admit Card

Download EESL Assistant Engineer, Assistant Manager Syllabus 2017

Unknown said...

This is very interesting content! I have thoroughly enjoyed reading your points and have come to the conclusion that you are right about many of them. You are great.
SSC Calendar 2018

Unknown said...

Very good information thank you for sharing.A very useful website specially for the sarkari results and latest news in India govt jobs get here
Upcoming Govt Jobs 2017-18

Unknown said...

Thanks for sharing information. Very informative .Click here for SSC Jobs

Unknown said...

ISRO Scientist/Engineer Admit Card 2017, Check the exam dates: – Indian Space Research Organization (ISRO) will be going to recruit 80 vacant posts.

Unknown said...

Thanks for sharing information.
India Results 2017

Unknown said...

Good information.Thanks for sharing.
MPPSC Tehsildar Recruitment

hhiii said...

Amazing news for the candidates who are in search of the government jobs. IBPS has announced the vacancies in the PO cadre across the India. All the eligible and interested candidates can have a glance over the detailed notification of the IBPS.
bandcamp.com/johannaskolan
johannaskolan-com.hatenablog.com

koooooo said...

Here is all about jio phone.
Jio phone specifications

Palak said...

Thanks for giving this helpful information on your site.
NTSE Result

jhon said...

The receipt can then be automatically moved to the Deleted Items folder or any other folder that you choose. Coworking Spaces

Anonymous said...

Thanks for the informative post dear.

ojas said...

up police admit card
up police constable admit card

Unknown said...

sey photo
katrina hot image
photo hot photo
all actress hot photos
hot picture image
hindi actress photos
saxy image photos
full hot image
indian hot photos
hot picks images

Unknown said...

This is very interesting content! I have thoroughly enjoyed reading your points and have come to the conclusion that you are right about many of them. You are great.

CCS University Meerut BA 1st/ 2nd/ 3rd Year Results 2018

Unknown said...

Its a great pleasure reading your post.Its full of information I am looking .SSC CHSL Notification
SSC CHSL Syllabus

Vicky Tawde said...

Thanks for sharing this information with us, i always like to read these articles, cool..! I always like to read such information regarding that topic so please keep it up and keep sharing..
24JobsExam Free Jobs Alert News Latest Govt Jobs ||
Check 24JobsExam Bankers Adda Placement Store of Jobs, Employment News

Unknown said...

The Chanakya National Law University, Going release the admit card for CLAT 2018, Candidates Can Download Their CLAT Admit Card 2018, CLAT Hall Ticket, CLAT Hall Ticket, From Official Website.

CLAT Admit Card 2018

Somyapatel said...

How much of what transpired will lead to further communication and action, and how much represented a “smoke and mirrors” game by officials of the Department remains to be seen Answer Key 2018.

Unknown said...

Nice Blog Thanks for sharing such useful details with us.
Answer key 2018

Unknown said...

12th Pass Govt Jobs

Travel nearby said...

This is a wonderful article, Given so much info in it, You can see travel nearby best tourist place Best Honeymoon Destination in this page.These type of articles keeps the user's interest in the website.

Travel Nearby
Best Tourist Place in India
Tourist Place in Jaipur

Travel nearby said...

Thanks have been given the opportunity to comment. Hopefully what you provided is useful for all those who need them. Visit my website if you want to know more about.
chatpati latest news
Top Stories News Headlines
Business News
Hot Actress pics
latest Upcoming Movies
latest news videos

Travel nearby said...


Thanks for sharing such beautiful information with us This is a wonderful article, Given so much info in it, You can see Travel Nearby best tourist place Best Honeymoon Destination in this page.



Thanks for sharing such beautiful information with us This is a wonderful article, Given so much info in it, You can see Travel Nearby best tourist place Best Honeymoon Destination in this page.
Travel Destination Near Manali
Beautifull Hill Station Shimla for Couples
Tourist Place Near Kasauli
Weekend Destination near Chamba
Weekend Destination near Kufri
Best Honeymoon Destination in India
Places to visit in Dharamshala
Places to visit in Kasol
Places to visit in Kinnaur

Travel nearby said...

Thanks a bunch for sharing this with all of us you actually know what you are talking about! Bookmarked. Please also visit my site.
Most Beautiful & Stunning Waterfalls in Kerala
Most FamousTourist Places in Kerala
Travel Destination places Near Munnar
Beautifull Hill Station Devikulam for Couples
Tourist Place Near Kumarakom
Weekend Destination near Kovalam
Tourist Places to Visit in Kollam

Unknown said...

All Free Upcoming State Govt Jobs Alerts Jobs 2018 General Knowedge and Current Affairs Updates

BPO and IT Jobs best Indias Job Website Latest ITI jobs and Diploma jobs

Travel nearby said...

Thanks have been given the opportunity to comment. Hopefully what you provided is useful for all those who need them. Visit my website if you want to know more about.

E aadhar card
Aadhar card download
Check Aadhar Card Status by name & moblie no.
e aadhar card update
Uidai help enquiry
Aadhar Card Correction

Travel nearby said...


Home Loan Emi Calculator
Car loan Emi Calculator
Personal Loan Emi Calculator
Education Loan Emi Calculators
Two Wheeler Loan Emi Calculator
Credit Card Loan Emi Calculator

Unknown said...

Much obliged to you for sharing such extraordinary data. It has help me in discovering more insight about Educational Loan Interest Rate

sd said...

We Need More Articles

flipkart offers said...




flipkart big shopping days,
flipkart big shopping days sale,
flipkart big shopping days 2018,
flipkart big shopping days offers,
flipkart big shopping days sale 2018,
flipkart next big shopping days,
big shopping days in flipkart,
flipkart online shopping big billion day,
flipkart big apple shopping day,
flipkart big shopping days 2017,
flipkart big shopping days terms and conditions,
flipkart big shopping days sbi offer,
flipkart big shopping days hdfc offer,
flipkart big shopping days mobiles,
flipkart big shopping days 2018 redmi note 5 pro,
flipkart big shopping days 2018 offers,
flipkart big shopping days date,
flipkart big shopping days hdfc,
flipkart big shopping days oppo f7,
flipkart big billion day online shopping,
big app shopping days in flipkart,
flipkart big shopping days 2016,
flipkart big shopping days 2017 sbi offer,
flipkart big shopping days july 2018,
flipkart big shopping days may,
flipkart big shopping days may 2018

Nino Nurmadi , S.Kom said...

Easy Indonesian CoursesLearning Indonesia
Indonesia Courses
Indonesia Courses
www.lampungservice.com
Service HP
lampungservice.com
Makalah Bisnisilmu konten
Vivo

flipkart offers said...

citibank offer flipkart
flipkart citi offer
flipkart citibank credit card offer
flipkart citi credit card offers
flipkart citibank
flipkart citibank cash back
citi flipkart offer
citibank flipkart offer
flipkart citibank cashback offer
citibank debit card offers
citibank offers credit card
citibank offers on mobiles
citibank credit card offers
citibank offers
citibank iphone offer
citibank card offers
citibank iphone offer
citibank offer
citibank offers
citibank credit card iphone offer
citi credit card offers
cash back offer citibank
citibank cash back card
flipkart credit card
citibank iphone cashback offer
citi card offers
citibank credit card instant payment
citibank cash back offer
cashback offers on citibank credit card
city bank credit card offers
citibank credit card cash back offer
citi bank offers
citibank credit card emi
get citibank credit card
citi cash back card
to day offer flipkart
citi credit card payment through debit card
citibank emi payment
city bank credit card bill pay
citibank credit card discount
flipkart citibank cards offer
flipkart citibank cards

krishna said...

\
flipkart hdfc,
flipkart hdfc offer,
flipkart hdfc credit card offer,
flipkart offers for hdfc credit card,
flipkart hdfc offer terms and conditions,
flipkart hdfc debit card emi
flipkart hdfc card offers
flipkart hdfc debit card offer
flipkart hdfc debit card emi offer
flipkart hdfc offer 2018
flipkart hdfc terms and conditions
flipkart hdfc smart buy
flipkart sale hdfc offer
flipkart hdfc bank
flipkart emi hdfc debit card
flipkart coupons for hdfc
flipkart hdfc promo code
flipkart hdfc credit card emi
flipkart offer with hdfc credit card
flipkart hdfc emi offer
flipkart hdfc emi
flipkart hdfc no cost emi
flipkart hdfc sale
flipkart and hdfc offer
flipkart and hdfc
flipkart and hdfc credit card offer
flipkart discount hdfc credit card
flipkart freedom sale hdfc offer
flipkart hdfc 10 instant discount
flipkart hdfc bank offer 2017
flipkart hdfc offer 2017
flipkart hdfc offer august 2017
flipkart hdfc offer may 2017
flipkart loan from hdfc
flipkart hdfc offer july 2017

Anonymous said...

https://mix.com/cvlampungservicehttp://kingcameranfoundation.ning.com/profiles/blogs/best-indonesian-courseshttps://medium.com/@lampungservice.comhttp://lampung.wikidot.com/main:layout
https://makalahbiz.blogspot.com/m
https://jalanbumisarinatar.blogspot.com.http://lampungservice.comtempatservicehpdibandarlampung.blogspot.com

krishna said...


Flipkart CashBack Offers,telugu bloggers ,telugu websites

Flipkart CashBack Offers - SBI, HDFC, ICICI, Citibank Cards,flipkart sbi debit card emi,flipkart upcoming offers on mobiles,flipkart credit card,flipkart cashback phonepe,flipkart credit card generator,flipkart cashback offer phonepe,flipkart american express,india fake debit card generator,flipkart american express gift card,sbi credit card offers on flipkart today,sbi flipkart offer,sbi debit card offers cash back,sbi flipkart offer 2018,,telugu bloggers ,telugu websites


Offers.Flipkart .

flipkart bank offers,flipkart cash back coupons, flipkart offers,flipkart cashback offers ,flipkart cashback offers,flipkart cash back offers,flipkart cashback coupons,flipkart cashback,Flipkart Cashback Offers,Flipkart Bank Offers, flipkart upcoming offers on mobiles, flipkart hdfc offer, flipkart icici offer,sbi credit card offers on flipkart today,sbi flipkart offer, hdfc credit card offers on flipkart, flipkart upcoming offers on mobiles, flipkart offers


flipkart today deal offer,flipkart todays deal,flipkart best offer today,flipkart cashback offer today,flipkart mobile app offers today,flipkart mobile deals today

"Flipkart Cashback Offers || Flipkart Bank Offers || Flipkart Deals 2018 ||" "flipkart upcoming offers on mobiles, hdfc credit card offers on flipkart 2018, sbi credit card offers on flipkart today, flipkart hdfc offer terms and conditions, sbi flipkart offer 2018, flipkart cashback phonepe, flipkart hdfc offer august 2018, flipkart icici offers

Flipkart CashBack Offers July 2018 - SBI, HDFC, ICICI, Citibank Cards,Cashback Offers Coupons,

Today Special deals offers

krishna said...



Flipkart CashBack Offers June 2018 - SBI, HDFC, ICICI, Citibank Cards

Best of Home Furnishing min 40% off:

flipkart Mobile Accessories,flipkart Storage devices,flipkart Brands at best prices,flipkart Top Offers,flipkart Fashion for Travel Lovers,FLIPKART Great Offers On Furniture,FLIPKART Discounts for You,flipkart Deals of the Day


flipkart axis cashback offer,

flipkart discount coupon codes, flipkartcashbackoffers,

vishal1 said...

It was really pleasure to read such a beautiful piece of Article. It just should have elaborated more to get the proper insights but if you are looking for more information just continue to - Educational Loan Emi Calculator

Erin Moses said...

Canon support
hp printer helpline number

raviroy7738 said...

Its great to know about this blog, Appreciate your efforts with such a valuable information provided. Could you help me to find out more details about Education Loan EMI Calculator

Vikas Kumar said...

Thanks for sharing such an informative post. you can check career
Bookmyshow Offers
Ticketnew Offers
AbhiBus Coupons
Railway Jobs
Walk in Jobs
Off Campus Jobs
Jobs in Karnataka

Mukul said...

Zoylo Coupons
Zoomin Coupons
Zomato Coupons
Zoff Foods Coupons
Zivar Coupons

Anurag Srivastava said...

I want to thank you for this excellent read...Postal Recruitment 2020is the great news for candidates looking for jobs in the post office

Ruhi Sukhla said...

This article is rich with content. आरबीएसई 12वीं आर्ट्स का रिजल्ट name wise

Birth Certificate said...

Change of name in birth certificate in delhi

Birth certificate correction in Delhi

Marriage Certificate in Delhi

naukriname said...

Candidates who are searching for a government job after their school or college education visit Naukriname and Candidates who are searching for Biography visit vefeed

Unknown said...

Norton Error During Quick Scan

Unknown said...

bitsourceit

Unknown said...

Best SEO Company in Lahore

Nock Code said...

Best SEO Company in Dubai
Best SEO Company in Dubai
Best SEO Company in Dubai
Best SEO Company in Dubai
Best SEO Company in Dubai

RojgarExpress.com said...

Very Good Post, Keep Sending Us Such Informative Articles I Visit Your Website On a Regular Basis.
rojgarexpress

Arabic Sweets said...

Delivery Services in Dubai
Delivery Services

Sarkari Job Career said...

Download Central & State Govt Jobs Syllabus Pdf – All Competetive Exam Syllabus and Exam Pattern Click Here

Sarkari Job Career said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
sugoi dekai meaning said...


a Girl or Boy? What’s the gender of Kurapika? Before knowing the gender of Kurapika, let us tell you that Kurapika is an anime character from the very famois kurapika a girl
Is Kurapika us manga series Hunter

sugoi dekai meaning said...

intricate text meaning

Awais.Endemaj said...

Investment Company in Dubai
Financial Companies in Dubai
Financial Company in Dubai

Learn English said...

Hi there it’s me, I am also visiting this site daily, this site is truly
good and the viewers are actually sharing good thoughts
Jobdil

IkramAli78511 said...

Dog shopping online

Fsmbuddy12 said...

music classes in sura

davi said...

This is really interesting and worth reading your post. I should highly appreciate the efforts you put in. This is amazing and exciting Online Shopping in Paksitan

davi said...

Great post with great content, just randomly came here and i must say you save a great way of presentation. Best motivational Quotes 2021

Unknown said...

techfizzi

Unknown said...

nice post , i am looking such this type content ,fanilly found this here



if you fonder off news then visit our site ,link is given below
news pakistan


if you are food lover ,then visit our site ,link is given below


food desi

Muzammil habib said...

shipping-from-dubai-to-lebanona

fsmbuddy123 said...

23b-PVP / Buy 23B-PVP Online

ahmad faraz said...

Shipping From Dubai To Australia

Ammar Qureshi said...

Quality Profile Backlinks for Website SEO

Unknown said...

premionetwork

Online advertisement said...

WordPress.com is the best free WordPress platform that you can find. Because unlike WordPress.org, here the site takes care of all the hostings for you.

free wordpress hosting

Online advertisement said...

Infinity free is one of the best free WordPress hosting providers out there, providing unlimited bandwidth and disk space for its free users.

free wordpress hosting

travel said...


Roof dripping becomes a common problem during the rainy season. Pak Chemical Services provides the best services to its customers are among our priorities.
Living Lasting and Quality Use
Using the product according to the condition
Getting your work done in the best way possible
Our featured services include
Roof water proofing
Roof heat insulation, protecting the roof from the heat of the sun called Roof Coal Services
If the water tank is leaking, waterproofing it after repairing it
Flats often have bathroom leakage problems
Pak Chemical Services Company solves all these problems with 3, 5, 7 and 10 years treatment guarantee. For more information, please call us. Thank you.

Roof Leakage Solution karachi

SEO King said...

What to Watch on Netflix

SEO King said...


十和田湖

Unknown said...

Visit This Site
Nice Post
high quality backlinks for google top ranking
professional graphic designer,freelance graphic designer
professional graphic designer,freelance graphic designer
50 social bookmarking submissions with high da backlinks
50 social bookmarking submissions with high da backlinks
do high authority web 2 0 backlinks

Ahmad 3 Alli62 said...

low pressure switch

SEO Agency Dhanot said...

Dubai Business Directory

Muzammil habib said...

Prime Electrical Contracting Company L.L.C

Muzammil habib said...

https://www.blogger.com/comment.g?blogID=18612102&postID=114288335759464767&page=1&token=1638361683329

Muzammil habib said...

Conversion Electromechanical Co. LLC

Muzammil habib said...

United Master Electromechanical L.L.C

Muzammil habib said...

Al Rigga Massage Center In Dubai

Muzammil habib said...

Friends Massage Center

Muzammil habib said...

Orchid Tobacco Dubai

Muzammil habib said...

Emirates NBD Bank

Muzammil habib said...

Diva Abaya Couture – Wafi Mall :

Muzammil habib said...

Aryan Business Consulting Fz LLC

Muzammil habib said...

Commitbiz Business Setup Consultants Dubai

Muzammil habib said...

Animal Welfare Abu Dhabi

Muzammil habib said...

United Emirates Metals & Abrasives LLC

Muzammil habib said...

Abdul Rahim Architectural Consultants

Muzammil habib said...

AL Hadi Air Condition Systems LLC

Muzammil habib said...

CAD GULF LLC WAREHOUSE

Muzammil habib said...

Al Ghurair University

Muzammil habib said...

Prime Air Conditioning Company

Muzammil habib said...

Fort Equity Dubai

Muzammil habib said...

NMC Royal Hospital, DIP

Muzammil habib said...

NODE-NETWORKING COMPANY

Muzammil habib said...

AC Duct cleaning

Online advertisement said...

KMSpico is software for those who avoid violating the rules of Microsoft. It is a very handy software for everyone in terms of regular technology.


kmspico

Muzammil habib said...

S.K.M. Air Conditioning LLC

Muzammil habib said...

Al Ghaimah HVAC Contracting

Muzammil habib said...

Arctic Mount AC Systems Maintenance LLC

Muzammil habib said...

Trosten Industries Company LLC

Muzammil habib said...

AC Duct Cleaning Services LLC Dubai UAE

Muzammil habib said...

BBC Movers and Packers Services Dubai

Muzammil habib said...

Dubai Air-Conditioning Co LLc

Muzammil habib said...

Social media marketing agency in Dubai| Pentacodes IT Solutions

Muzammil habib said...

Portable Toilet and Sanitation by Eco Planet

Muzammil habib said...

Mindrnd

Muzammil habib said...

IPEC - Odour Control

Muzammil habib said...

Mermaid Digital Printing

Muzammil habib said...

https://companylisting.ae/directory/srilankan-airlines/

Muzammil habib said...

Turkish Airlines Inc.

Muzammil habib said...

Pakistan International Airlines

Muzammil habib said...

Al Ramah Hardware Trading Co LLC

Muzammil habib said...

Vanan Captioning

Muzammil habib said...

AG CARS Services LLC

Muzammil habib said...

Alsayegh Media

Muzammil habib said...

TRC Pamco Middle East

Unknown said...

AC Maintenance Services Dubai

SEO Agency Dhanot said...

Refrigerator Repairing, Fridge Repairing Service


Are you seeking Fridge and Refrigerator Repairing Services near you? Contact us Now to receive a discounted rate if you complete the contact form on our website. Our lives are very busy and it appears that there's a lot of laundry to wash. Therefore, it's not a great issue that the washers in (Dubai, Ajman and Sharjah) wear out every now and then and we'll need an engineer, mechanic, or technician to repair the washing Machine in the shortest amount of time or you can just call a Local Man in your area.

ahmad faraz said...

blogger in dubai

Unknown said...

23b-pvp

Unknown said...

dire flail 5e

Unknown said...

shopify web design agency

Unknown said...

grimoire infinitus

Unknown said...

top shipping companies in dubai

electrofakhar said...

Thank you for sharing


 Recette osso bucco

 Protection juridique macif

Kemai chemical (Europe) GmbH said...

Awesome and interesting article. Great things you've always shared with us. Thanks. Just continue composing this kind of post. please guys check our website https://kemaichemgmbh.com/shop/

ahmad said...

money robot review

ahmad said...

23b pvp

ahmad72 said...

Estrenos Doramas

ahmad said...


Wow, What an Outstanding post. I found this too much informatics.
It is what I was seeking for. I would like to recommend you that please keep sharing such type of info.If possible, Thanks.
Satta king 786

AssamSakori said...

assam advertisement
assam career job

Anupama said...

Anupamaa is an Indian Hindi-language television drama series that premiered on 13 July 2020 on Star Plus.
Anupamaa, who parts with her ambitions and goals in a bid to raise her family, feels dejected when she fails to get any credit for her sacrifices and trials. She then decides to live on her own terms.
Watch Video Anupama,Latest Full Episode Online, Star Plus Drama Anupama Episode and Complete Today Episode on Dailymotion, Desi Serial Watch Anupama.

Just the website i was looking for. It's really awesome. I'll follow your footsteps
and if you want to watch melayu or indian dramas online free episodes daily then visit the link below.

Anupama online

davi said...

one of the quality and amazing information I have found here..! headphones price in Pakistan

Training Delhi said...

HR Generalist Training In Delhi

Creditap said...

Thanks for sharing this blog! reach us at - school fees funding

Weed said...

As sporting use cannabis cultivators seek top-offering - the most THC concentrated item - clients are cherishing it. With more significant levels of THC, the clients can get higher, faster.
Mail Order Marijuana

Ammar Qureshi said...

Magazine News Tech

ahmad said...

lisbon photographer

ahmad said...

Ultra Heal

Dippy Diary said...

how many 40ft containers fit on a cargo ship"

Dippy Diary said...

how to get a job on a cargo ship"

Dippy Diary said...

what home improvements increase property taxes"

Dippy Diary said...

how much does a cargo ship captain make"

Dippy Diary said...

what education is needed to become a film director"

Kepala Bergetar said...

Kepala Bergetar is a Malaysian online streaming platform that provides a wide range of television series, movies, dramas, and other content for viewers to watch online. It is a popular website in Malaysia where people can access a diverse collection of content in the Malay language. Kepala Bergetar

Dippy Diary said...

how technology has changed culture"

Dippy Diary said...

where is milan fashion week 2022 held"

hindiexamalert said...

Hindi Exam Alert is an education website where you can get latest update about Sarkari Job
, Result, Admit Card, Syllabus, GK, and Education News

greenbox1509 said...

Best Digital Marketing Services in Abu Dhabi

ahmad said...

wholesale jeans suppliers

Henry said...

Kanata Locksmith: Your local experts in locksmith services. Reliable solutions for lockouts, key replacements, and security needs. Trust us for prompt and professional service.
A1 Appliance