Friday, January 16, 2015

A Few Thoughts on the Testing Crisis and Attacks on Public Education



1. Although there is no evidence that a stagnant public school system has been a major cause of growing poverty and inequality in the United States- which is in large part caused by wage compression, outsourcing of jobs,  regressive tax policies and the burdens imposed by a huge and expensive prison industrial complex- many liberals have decided that a revamped and privatized public education system, carefully monitored and regulated by the federal government, represents out the only realistic hope of breaking the cycle of poverty. This is partly wishful thinking, but it also represents a cold assessment of political reality, because liberals view school reform is the only anti-poverty strategy that has any hope of gaining bi-partisan support.

2. Once you decide to make the schools the major instrument of reducing inequality, your focus inevitably turns to teachers and teachers unions, who, in stead of being seen as allies in this effort, are increasingly seen as obstacles to the great national crusade. Many liberals have convinced themselves that if teachers feet are not held to the fire by nationally mandated tests and test based evaluations, they will spend their time baby sitting low income students rather than teaching them. This pessimistic assessment of the nation's teaching force underlies every pronouncement of the Duncan headed US Department of Education, who sees teachers as part of the problem rather than part of the solution.

3. We have now had nearly 15 years ( since 2011) of the bi-partisan school reform crusade launched by No Child Left behind, and by every indicator- from child poverty, to racial wealth gaps, to housing quality and distribution of income across the racial and economic spectrum- poverty and inequality have grown in the US. Has this led liberals to question using Test based school reform and attacks on teachers and teachers unions as their major strategy for achieving equity? No! To judge by what is happening in New York State with Governor Cuomo, and in the US Department of Education, they are doubling down on failed policies.

4.Eventually, the nation will wake up to the fact that School Reform is a disastrous anti-poverty strategy, especially when that strategy involves deluging schools with tests, closing neighborhood public schools and terrorizing, scripting and micromanaging teachers, but by that time, the nation's public schools may have suffered near fatal damage.

Time is short. Many conservatives see the damage imposed by excessive testing. Liberals had better wake up

8 comments:

Sandra Lee said...

I can agree with the post, because education is an important part of the developed society and the possibility to make good and well-educated new generation. However such reforms that were held are not appropriate and will never prevent poverty. I think that teachers should be supported and be the first who make changes to the existing educational program. I think they know the process of education better than all politics and should create a program for necessary changes. To support such idea schools can contact direct lenders operating 24/7 online in order to have additional income to held such changes.

Kuldeep said...

Kar Board 12th Time Table
RPSC Teacher Syllabus
RRB Bhopal
Raj University Result
RBSE Date Sheet

Yasmin Priya said...

Thanks for share this information. I have read your blog. Your information is really helpful for me. Keep update your blog. Selenium training in Chennai

murali karthik said...

Thanks for your informative article on software testing. Your post helped me to understand the future and career prospects in software testing. Keep on updating your blog with such awesome article. Software testing course in Chennai| Software testing training in Chennai

Vishal Saini said...

JKBOSE 10th Result
Gujarat Board SSC Result
Kerala SSLC
MP Board High School Result
NiOS 10th Result
Punjab Board 10th Result
TS Board SSC Result
TN Board SSLC Result
Tripura Board Madhyamic Result
UK Board X Result

Divya Saini said...


hbse 12th class result
assam 12th result
cgbse board 10th result
bseb matric result
gujarat board ssc result
goa ssc result
hbse bhiwni ssc result
assam hs result

Hardik Tanwar said...



Uniraj MA,MSC 3rd Sem Admit Card
Uniraj MA,MVA 1st Sem Admit Card
RU Mcom 1st Sem Call letter
Uniraj MA, Admit Card
UOR MSC 1st Sem Admit Card
Rajasthan Uni. MA,MVA Hall Ticket
Uniraj MA,Music 1st Sem Admit Card
Uniraj LLM 3rdSem Admit Card
RU LLM HRVE 3rd Sem Call Letter

Abinaya V said...

If the graduation rates are up and the NAEP scores are up, then the schools are not in “crises”, right?

Why do you want it both ways, pbmeyer? R Programming Training | DataStage Training | SQL Training | SAS Training | Android Training | SharePoint Training