Monday, July 20, 2015

Color Blind = Tone Deaf. A Message to Bernie Sanders from Jane DeNeefe

I am on the ground in Alabama, an author of two books about the civil rights movement and co-director of an African American history project--  and I can attest, Bernie is losing black support that was already flimsy--I'd give him a C for Netroots Nation, which is generous, and better than O'Malley's F but still not good enough--he sounds like an old white man  who was current on race fifty years ago but who is now "colorblind" which equals tone deaf on the state of race relations  in this historical moment. This letter is a follow-up to one I wrote the campaign in early June about Bernie’s approach to race relations.

There are things he can do to improve his thinking about race that will also improve his responses.  If no one is stepping up to educate him on this, I can do it, but I would need his attention--I've had enough of pissing in the wind.  I want to know the message will land before I go to the trouble to craft it. I could publish about this but I would rather educate Bernie directly than call him out in public.

I can't believe he isn't getting better advice about race.  The answer to "say her name" this week is “Sandra Bland." http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation-now/2015/07/18/sandra-bland-die-police-custody/30342377/

Bernie needs to catch up and stay current, because he is sounding too much like the *recipients* of MLK's letter from the Birmingham Jail--out of touch with the fact that black people in this country are in a state of emergency.  Bernie is better than this and it is CRUCIAL that he not--through unconscious accident-- deliver talking points that modern-day white supremacists use.  For example, suggesting that the BLM protestors “wait” until after the stump speech registered as an all-too-familiar dismissal of their urgency. It would have been better to improvise immediately by addressing their concerns first.  When MLK called out Birmingham’s white clergy, he wrote: “For years now I have heard the word ‘Wait!’ It rings in the ear of every Negro with piercing familiarity. This ‘Wait’ has almost always meant ‘Never.’ We must come to see, with one of our distinguished jurists, that ‘justice too long delayed is justice denied.’”

Bernie has made some effort to update his racial concepts but he needs to keep working on it by listening as well as by phrasing his points more carefully.  Frederick Douglass was not, in fact, talking about "all of us.”  Impoverished immigrant ancestors who chose to come here are NOT analogous to enslaved ancestors who were forced to come here.  Some issues are **specifically** African American and that needs to be acknowledged openly.  White supremacy is real and should be called out, not swept under the rug of progressive economic reform.  

Dallas was a slight improvement—but Sandra Bland et al should be referred to as “human beings" or as "citizens who died in police custody” not as “things like Sandra Bland...”  I am so worried that Bernie will say something clueless in Alabama, and from what I am seeing, the chances for a race relations gaff are high.  This isn't the time to defend Bernie's past record on race, but to learn from the moment about how to move forward effectively. 

Bernie can step up to this moment but he needs to do some serious homework and I will help, given the chance.  I am not the most skilled anti-racism educator in the country, not by a long shot, but I am willing to step up if no one else does. Bernie, from his national perch, has access to the best, and he should reach out and learn from them.  This is urgent.

Jane DeNeefe
Huntsville Alabama

10 comments:

Auburn said...

Well-spoken, Jane, and thank you.

JuanMesh said...

Hello, just for the record, he did say "names like Sandra Bland" not "things like Sandra Bland". https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iquADz8Yve4&t=53m42s

SpotMyMusic.com said...

I get the frustration. I am upset every time I hear about any black person that is killed by police or any racial injustice. This is real.. Real sad that in 2015 some things havent changed. I get it seems to be over looked because other than media coverage there has been no legal steps to eradiate it. So I get the movement, I am all for the movement. What I am not all for is how the movement decided to go about getting the issue discussed. It was very rude &

bothersome that they decided to yell, make jokes & dismiss bernie association with any civil rights events. It was like they took all of their frustration, well deserved, at bernie. I would have rather someone brought it up as a discussion bc im sure it would have been more productive. If he referred back to economics then explain thats its deeper than that. But dont berate the guy. He has taken great steps to improve upon his mistakes and shies promise to improve on his knowledge about racial issues & solutions but its still seems not good enough. I know for a fact that bernie sanders is the best candidate for our black community. I am all for challenging him. He will continue to improve as he is continually challenged. But challenge him fairly, in a productive manner that leads to a disscussion & help him understand deeper rooted issues. Dont yell and berate him. Please dont think that one group or one person represents the whole black community because I for one, although upset at racial injustice, am a black voter for bernie sanders & i know many others. Hillary is history for me.

SpotMyMusic.com said...

I get the frustration. I am upset every time I hear about any black person that is killed by police or any racial injustice. This is real.. Real sad that in 2015 some things havent changed. I get it seems to be over looked because other than media coverage there has been no legal steps to eradiate it. So I get the movement, I am all for the movement. What I am not all for is how the movement decided to go about getting the issue discussed. It was very rude &

bothersome that they decided to yell, make jokes & dismiss bernie association with any civil rights events. It was like they took all of their frustration, well deserved, at bernie. I would have rather someone brought it up as a discussion bc im sure it would have been more productive. If he referred back to economics then explain thats its deeper than that. But dont berate the guy. He has taken great steps to improve upon his mistakes and shies promise to improve on his knowledge about racial issues & solutions but its still seems not good enough. I know for a fact that bernie sanders is the best candidate for our black community. I am all for challenging him. He will continue to improve as he is continually challenged. But challenge him fairly, in a productive manner that leads to a disscussion & help him understand deeper rooted issues. Dont yell and berate him. Please dont think that one group or one person represents the whole black community because I for one, although upset at racial injustice, am a black voter for bernie sanders & i know many others. Hillary is history for me.

SpotMyMusic.com said...

I get the frustration. I am upset every time I hear about any black person that is killed by police or any racial injustice. This is real.. Real sad that in 2015 some things havent changed. I get it seems to be over looked because other than media coverage there has been no legal steps to eradiate it. So I get the movement, I am all for the movement. What I am not all for is how the movement decided to go about getting the issue discussed. It was very rude &

bothersome that they decided to yell, make jokes & dismiss bernie association with any civil rights events. It was like they took all of their frustration, well deserved, at bernie. I would have rather someone brought it up as a discussion bc im sure it would have been more productive. If he referred back to economics then explain thats its deeper than that. But dont berate the guy. He has taken great steps to improve upon his mistakes and shies promise to improve on his knowledge about racial issues & solutions but its still seems not good enough. I know for a fact that bernie sanders is the best candidate for our black community. I am all for challenging him. He will continue to improve as he is continually challenged. But challenge him fairly, in a productive manner that leads to a disscussion & help him understand deeper rooted issues. Dont yell and berate him. Please dont think that one group or one person represents the whole black community because I for one, although upset at racial injustice, am a black voter for bernie sanders & i know many others. Hillary is history for me.

Jane DeNeefe said...

@JuanMesh--you are right, he did say 'names' not 'things'--I couldn't hear that on the version I was listening to, which has a lot of ambient noise. Thanks for the link.

Kuldeep said...

SSC CHSL Answer Key
RRB Mumbai
Orissa CHSE Date Sheet
PSEB 12th Date Sheet
RBSE 12th Date Sheet
Raj University Result

Divya Saini said...


RRB Bhubaneswar admit card
RRB Chennai admit card
RRB Kolkata admit card
RRB Mumbai admit card
RRB Patna admit card

Hardik Tanwar said...



RU MSC Previous Physics Admit Card
RU BA Hons Call Letter
Goa Board SSC Result
JKBOSE 12th Results
MAH HSC Results

Hardik Tanwar said...



TBSE Madhyamik Result
NIOS 10th Result
MP High School Result
WB Madhyamik Result
UP High School Result
TN SSLC Result
PSEB 10th Result
MAH SSC Result
Odisha SSC Result
CGBSE 10th Result