Monday, September 7, 2015

Do Teachers Unions Need to Fight Harder for Their Members? Labor Day Reflections by Dr Patricia Robinson-Linder

On this Labor Day – and I am extremely grateful for it – I am collecting my thoughts with regard to my membership in labor unions. For the record, I have all my life held down two full-time careers, which necessitated my membership in eight labor unions. Most of them are part of the AFL-CIO. Two of my show business unions are affiliated with the Teamsters. Also, for the record, I belong to both of the teachers’ unions, the AFT and the NEA, as well as the professors’ union, the AAUP. I have been working in one of my careers since I was fifteen months old. At some point in my maturation, I decided that “the union can help you and the union can hurt you”. Clearly, I tried never to be naïve .Even so, in forty-five years of teaching, ten for the School District of Philadelphia, and more than sixty years in entertainment, there has been only one epic fail, and that was at the hands of the Philadelphia Federation of Teachers. First, allow me to say that I have no particular quarrel with the downtown, Chestnut Street representatives who connected with my schools. They were good, except in one way, and I now believe that that one tragic flaw was orchestrated somewhere on high and handed down through many layers of the American Federation of Teachers. Looking back, I believe I received no substantial warning from the teachers’ unions as to how the corporatization of education would affect us so negatively. I am referring to the advent and arrival of Common Core, the almost ridiculous and certainly obscure “newer” methods of teacher evaluation, the fervor of administrators to accept the garroting of highly-qualified, wonderfully-educated career faculty, including what I would call “smear campaigns,” and the bizarre and often pointless paperwork assignments (e.g. “back-mapping”) that kept us away from our preparation and execution of admirable classroom presentations, and our work with students, much of it individualized, that encouraged all students to internalize their lessons. Although I had been reading about it, the entire corporatization process remained something of an abstraction to me, something that would occur “in the future,” perhaps after I retired. Rather, in my last three years of teaching – and without the meetings that should have been called, the “coaching” of what one should do in these antagonistic situations, and the early and strong denunciation of some of School District of Philadelphia’s anti-education, anti-teacher practices, the whole corporatization initiative hit me fully in the face. The unions needed to protect us better. We needed full, direct warnings and instruction as to what to do to protect ourselves, the parents and guardians of our students, and, most of all, our students themselves.I fought through two years of the hostile chaos, battle-scarred beyond belief. The third and last year, just as I was about to file my retirement papers, in an irony that I view in a different light each day, I was hurt at school. Things had happened before, but not like this one – and yet I held no one at fault. Boys and girls will be boys and girls. Some youngsters running through the halls at the end of the week in some kind of a TGIF-energized moment, knocked me off my pins, and I flew into two walls. At first, I had a kind of lucidity, then I didn’t. Temple University told me that I was suffering from a double-concussion. I went into treatment that addressed some loss of memory, some trouble with the speech centers of the brain and those controlling coordination and spatial distances. My family doctor told me that “it would all come back”. My memory eventually returned in full in late April of my retirement year and the speech centers had cleared and re-aligned by February. Even with the best physical therapy, my balance never fully returned; I still watch out for myself in that regard. Ultimately, an old injury, incurred in theater work, was exacerbated by the new, and I now walk with a lift in my right shoe and, I’m sorry to say, with a limp.Retirement proceeded precisely as it should have, making me a retired employee of two states, Pennsylvania and Maryland, both of which were good to me. I have returned to college teaching and full-time theater and film work, yet I am haunted by that last year in public education. Somehow, I still feel the AFT had failed me, but if the concussions and other injuries had not occurred, could I have not done real, substantive teaching for those students, in spite of the unions’ failure to grasp the real gravity of it all, that would have set those young people on real lived lives and rewarding career paths? I suspect I will think about that one forever.

15 comments:

Ind Guru said...

Awesome information in the post

India Govt Jobs

Radha Kumari said...

thanks for the information and visiting to your website helps me a lot
17th October TSPSC AEE Answer Key 2015 Results cutoff Marks Merit List
MPPSC Assistant Geologist Answer Key Cut off Marks Merit List 2015

rajesh 1003 said...

Latest Govt Bank Jobs 2016

I truly appreciate this article post, thank you very much author

Memes King said...

will be following you along, thanks



govt jobs

Kuldeep said...

KVPY Answer Key
HPBOSE 10th Date Sheet
JAC 10th Date Sheet
JKBOSE 10th Date Sheet
govt. Jobs

Shruthi Kumari said...

Latest Govt Bank Jobs Notification 2016

Your site so great, thanks for all news post information

Golalaa Team said...

thanks for the information and visiting to your website helps me a lot
Govt result 2015

Neeraj Gaur said...

definetely they have to go for the fight
SSC CHSL Result 2015

Akula Rahul said...

ESIC Haryana Paramedical Staff Nurse Recruitment 2016

We need to thank admin for publishing useful information..........

Ramya Kolluru said...

Maharashtra Police Wireless HC ASI Recruitment 2016



This is awesome blog with smart content, Nice to see your post. Thanks.......

Tom Zing said...

nice post thanks for the information
Results 2016
Latest IBPS Updates
Latest recruitments
latest syllabus exam pattern
AP 10th Class Result 2016
AP SSC/ X Board Exam Grades

Divya Saini said...


AP SSC Results
HBSE 10th Result
UP Board High School Result
UPSC NDA Admit Card
UBTER Group C Call Letter
Uniraj Admit Card

Hardik Tanwar said...



RRB Bhubaneswar admit card
RRB Chennai admit card
RRB Kolkata admit card
RRB Mumbai admit card
RRB Patna admit card

soriya prashant said...

Good post artical
gs2
Government Recruitment
Jobs
Exam Results

Nikita Sharma said...

RRB Junior Accounts Asistant Cutoff
RRB Cutoff Marks
RRB Bangalore NTPC Result
RRB Bhopal NTPC Result
RRB Chandigarh NTPC Result
RRB Chennai NTPC Result
RRB Gorakhpur NTPC Result